After a long winter (shorter than a real winter), I’m back here. I must admit I have been having some issues with the concept of “science” and specially “science communication,” and sometimes if put me off writing. This is not new, but I’ll try to explain it this time.
I once read a best seller book called Freakonomics , which most of you may have already heard of. It uses the economic mindset and economic theories to study and understand non-economic topics, like the trends in naming children, frauds in sumo championships and the behaviour of real state agents.
It was written by an economist and a journalist, who I suppose was the responsible for making the text really fluid and easy to understand. It’s not a life-changing book, but I found it interesting.
Well, that’s how I feel about science. We should approach things scientifically – anything. Instead of just focusing on Physics, Biology, Mathematics and so on.
For example: just the other day I had a huge discussion with a friend about families, and how much should family interfere in people’s lives. I believe that the extreme of too much interference is preferable to the other extreme – no interference at all, you die alone and you will be found when the body begins to smell and the neighbours notice.
She was adamant that there is no reason to think in extremes, although her family history is on the non-interference extreme. My experience, in the contrary, is of being raised by a stereotypical Jewish mother (although we are not Jewish, as long as I know), and I don’t think it’s that bad.
Interestingly, I’ve never met any other son/daughter of similar mothers saying that this is terrible. But those who have distant mothers usually say that having an overprotective mother is the worst, most damaging thing in the world.
And no, I don’t believe in balance. I think all societies tend to exaggerate in a way: too much interference or no interference.
Well, the thing is that I got so mad with all that friend said that I decided to try and analyse the situation scientifically, instead of just focusing on how I feel about that.
I don’t know very well how to do it,but I would really appreciate comments on that. Does anyone share my feelings? Any idea on how to approach the topic scientifically?
PS: Here’s a Slate magazine slideshow about Jewish Mothers.