• The Gulf Stream by Kristi Vogel

    Environment, natural history, and academic culture along the Third Coast

    • Sugar, Fat, and Salt

      Sunday, 21 Jun 2009 - 22:56 UTC

      One of my domestic projects this month has been to use up fruit, tomato sauce, and pesto stored in my freezer, to make room for this year’s harvest from my garden and my friends’ ranch garden and fruit trees. The recent addition of my backyard garden will likely make it worthwhile to purchase a small chest freezer, but for now I need to make do with existing space. I should probably try canning some of the produce, but that’s a pretty labor-intensive venture. Typically, we have excellent yields of basil, tomatoes, peppers, and peaches, so that means I’ve been eating pasta with pesto, homemade vegetarian pizzas, and peach cobbler or lowfat yogurt fruit smoothies lately. Sounds like a reasonably healthy diet (for an American), but nevertheless, without 3+ gym sessions per week, horse-riding, daily walks with the dog, and swimming, my weight would be going in the wrong direction.

      Ohio WPA Art Program (1940)

      This food-related project coincides with reading David Kessler’s book The End of Overeating: Taking Control of the Insatiable American Appetite, on the recommendation of a friend (who, like Kessler, once worked for the FDA). In the first few chapters, we are introduced to several typical Americans (colleagues of Kessler), overweight and not, who struggle with resisting tempting, calorie-laden foods. These are not people with eating disorders; rather, they are responding to foods that are designed as highly rewarding and reinforcing stimuli, full of sugar, fat, and/or salt. Kessler describes neurobiological and psychological research that expands older models of eating modulated by homeostatic mechanisms, to include the nucleus accumbens (reward center in the ventral striatum), opioid circuits, dopamine-driven attention bias, and the reinforcing effects of multisensory stimuli. In the second section of the book, we learn how the food industry uses this information to develop complex products with a mix of attributes (mouthfeel, temperature, texture, viscosity, agreeable flavor combinations), which are highly palatable, hedonic, and salient. Some food industry buzzwords for you. Yeah.

      Herbert Bayer, for NYC WPA War Services (1941)

      As Kessler describes, hypereating and obesity are fairly recent trends in the US. Food is generally very plentiful, very convenient, and relatively inexpensive here, allowing people to consume cheap fat-, salt-, and sugar-laden foods quickly, and in all kinds of situations. It’s unusual to attend a meeting or seminar in an academic setting in the US at which there isn’t some sort of food on offer, and social gatherings associated with scientific conferences tend to revolve around food. Portion size is another example of a food-related norm that has changed in the past few decades (the most vigilant scientists identified statistics supporting an obesity trend in the US in the early 1980s). Americans snack more and are less physically active, and even the nature of a typical school lunch has changed. Take a look at the items listed on the WPA poster below, from the mid-1930s: a meat/vegetable dish (most likely soup), a sandwich (not this hamburger monstrosity), a piece of fruit, and milk to drink. No sugary soda or energy drink, no Fritos or Cheetos or Doritos or Megagorditos, no candy bar or Twinkie.

      WPA Oklahoma Art Project (1936)

      The End of Overeating is definitely not a standard diet book. There are no recipes, meal suggestions, exercise regimes, or calorie count tables. For some readers, an awareness of the manipulations used in the food industry, a recognition of the behavior patterns associated with conditioned hypereating, and the suggestions for how to avoid such unhealthy traps, will be very useful. I haven’t eaten the exact dishes at Chili’s or Panda Express that are described in the book, but reading about the ways in which the foods are prepared was enough to put me off eating at those restaurants again in the near (and possibly distant) future. I think I have a better understanding of why certain complex foods are so appealing and irresistible, and why I should avoid purchasing, or even looking at them, in the grocery store. Once that Ben and Jerry’s Imagine Whirled Peace or Phish Food ice cream is in the freezer at home, the temptation is too much.

      Last updated: Sunday, 21 Jun 2009 - 22:56 UTC

      • Comments

        • Date:
          Monday, 22 Jun 2009 - 20:07 UTC
          Cath Ennis said:

          Have you considered buying a dehydrator? I got one for $40 on Craigslist and it does wonders with our pears (although it’s a bit underpowered for the figs, and turns plums way too face-puckeringly sour). It might free some space in your freezer, and dried fruit makes the winter oatmeal a bit more interesting.

          I’m a bit too scared to read books like The End of Overeating, as I’m worried they’ll put me off restaurant food for the rest of my life.

        • Date:
          Monday, 22 Jun 2009 - 20:30 UTC
          Trisha Saha said:

          Hi Kristi! I read “Fat land” by Greg Critser for a class last semester. I can’t say I’ve changed my habits much since then but I am trying. I did learn quite a bit about HFCS and palm oil. I definitely want to check out “The End of Overeating.” Thanks for review. Also, pesto is AWESOME. :)

        • Date:
          Monday, 22 Jun 2009 - 23:22 UTC
          Kristi Vogel said:

          @ Cath – I forgot to mention that I have a dehydrator, and I love it. Though some things don’t last as long as I would like in this climate (and without artificial preservatives), so I end up keeping the dried fruits in the refrigerator. I’ve had quite good success with dehydrating peaches, mangoes, apples, tomatoes, and peppers. Dehydrated strawberries are weird, though. I like making lowfat granola, and I use the dried peaches and mangoes for that. If mangoes seem decadent, keep in mind that I’m close to Mexico, and can pick up inexpensive crates of beautiful mangoes at roadside stands, on birding trips to the Valley. We use the dried tomatoes and peppers on pizzas and in pasta sauces.

          @ Trisha – I haven’t read Critser’s book; would you recommend it? I liked Kessler’s book because of the neuroscience research discussion, but the very short chapters annoyed me a bit.

          Pesto is awesome. We grow 4 to 6 varieties of basil every year, and harvest the plants for pesto several times. You can get large bags of pine nuts at Costco for a reasonable price (though this is another bag that ends up in the freezer). I freeze pesto in ice cube trays, and then I have serving-size portions on hand.


Search blogs

web feed Want a blog?

Submit this post to

Advertisement