• Dr Grump's Emporium of Scientific Delights by Clare Dudman

    Dr Drusilla E Grump is the fictional persona of Clare Dudman. She will use this emporium to highlight misconceptions of science (as she sees them) in the media and elsewhere.

    • In which Dr Grump formally introduces herself.

      Sunday, 30 Nov 2008 - 12:48 UTC

      Dear fellow scientist,

      It is with heavy heart that I feel compelled to start this blog. For several months now my colleague, Dr Dudman (a lapsed scientist- although at one time quite distinguished in the field in the art of building rigs for studying the sensitivity of surface acoustic wave gas sensors and also in the manufacture of molecules of indeterminate floppiness containing both heterocyclic rings and ferrocene), has been urging me to do so.

      ‘You have so much to offer, Drusilla,’ she told me – and of course I agreed. I am an expert in two fields – etymology and sexual dynamics – which gives me a singular insight into several areas of human endeavour. Furthermore I am a lead researcher at the distinguished university of Uurm, an institution of burgeoning importance in both areas.

      More importantly, I am gorgeous. More – much more – on this topic later, perhaps. But for now I should just mention at the outset that

      I am six feet tall with a slim, well-proportioned figure (a little apple, a little pear) with the sort of hair that could easily grace a l’Oreal Herbalist advertisement: thick, luxuriant and black with exotic bluish overtones.

      Ah, but I am here for my mind rather than for my body I remind myself, and this too is extraordinary and beautiful. It has embraced so much, but mainly it embraces science. It has loved science with a passion usually reserved for bedroom scenes in a bad movie. Which leads me back to why, this morning, I felt compelled to start this blog.

      You see, I found my colleague, Dr Dudman, slumped miserably across her desk grasping the editorial from Friday’s Daily Telegraph in her hand.
      ‘Look,’ she said, ’that’s what they think – even now. You need to do something.’

      So I took it gently from her grasp and carefully smoothed out the slightly soggy paper. She had highlighted the offending words with her favourite green highlighter.

      ‘…Mr Blumenthal is famous for cooking up ideas in a test-tube. But cookery, like music or love, is not hatched in a laboratory. Frankenstein’s monster or chemical war are confected there. By contrast, eating is a humane activity, like playing a game or singing for joy….’

      That’s what made me snap, dear reader, and this is what finally drove me here.

      This is from the editorial comment from the UK’s largest selling quality newspaper, and he believes that a laboratory is not the place for ‘humane activity’ ‘playing a game’ or ‘singing for joy’.

      Dr Grump, however, intends to differ…

      …but that will have to come later. Just now I have to sort out next week’s subject rota.

      So, until next time, I would like to wish you a successful interlude with much singing and playing.

      And may all your monsters be kindly ones.

      Your humble and obedient servant,

      Drusilla E Grump.

      Last updated: Sunday, 30 Nov 2008 - 12:48 UTC

      • Comments

        • Date:
          Sunday, 30 Nov 2008 - 14:04 UTC
          Brian Clegg said:

          Welcome, Dr Grump. In case anyone is unfamiliar with your colleague, she blogs here

        • Date:
          Sunday, 30 Nov 2008 - 14:05 UTC
          Brian Clegg said:

          PS I think you ought to get someone to change the heading of this blog. It says you are a fictional persona. Clearly you can’t be, or you couldn’t write a blog. You must be a real, but reclusive person I feel.

        • Date:
          Sunday, 30 Nov 2008 - 14:45 UTC
          Clare Dudman said:

          Dr Grump says tell that Brian Clegg that he is clearly not a a fiction writer – if he were he would understand the term ‘fictional persona’.

          She is not called Dr Grump for nuthin.

          The heading stays.

        • Date:
          Sunday, 30 Nov 2008 - 15:15 UTC
          Bob O'Hara said:

          How do we know Clare Dudman isn’t a fictional persona, just pretending to be a real person?

        • Date:
          Sunday, 30 Nov 2008 - 16:02 UTC
          Clare Dudman said:

          Well Bob, I just asked Dr Grump that one (rather nervously because I know she is particularly tetchy when she is in the middle of her rotas) but she said nothing, just smiled mysteriously.

          When I asked her if she’d heard me she just replied ‘Go figure.’

          Whatever that means.

        • Date:
          Sunday, 30 Nov 2008 - 17:29 UTC
          Bob O'Hara said:

          Ah. It’s never good to talk to imaginary people.

        • Date:
          Sunday, 30 Nov 2008 - 17:48 UTC
          Maxine Clarke said:

          Welcome, Dr G. I look forward to more of your acerbic comments: I am sure there is a lot of suitable material out there – fortunately or unfortunately, depending on your viewpoint.

          I don’t think I’ll be visiting Mr Blumenthal’s Little Chef restaurant in the near future: I gather that he has done away with their trademark Maple Syrup Waffles (not real Maple Syrup, you understand, but Maple Syrup-Substitute).

        • Date:
          Sunday, 30 Nov 2008 - 18:18 UTC
          Henry Gee said:

          Excuse me, Madam, but does this bus go to the station?

        • Date:
          Sunday, 30 Nov 2008 - 19:10 UTC
          Clare Dudman said:

          Furthermore, Maxine, he is not intending to serve his snail porridge – I mean, what is the point of a Little Chef without snail porridge?

          And Henry, Dr Grump says ‘Are you talking to me?’

        • Date:
          Sunday, 30 Nov 2008 - 20:09 UTC
          Martin Fenner said:

          Welcome Dr. Grump, I’m looking forward to more blog posts from you. And please tell your colleague Dr. Dudman that I received her book 98 Reasons for Being in the mail today. Even though every German child knows Struwwelpeter, it is rather difficult to obtain a copy here in Germany.

        • Date:
          Sunday, 30 Nov 2008 - 20:20 UTC
          Clare Dudman said:

          Dr Grump says that is very kind of you to buy Dr Dudman’s book, Martin, and says that the best bits, in her opinion, are the pictures. She prefers Jilly Cooper.

        • Date:
          Sunday, 30 Nov 2008 - 22:04 UTC
          Heather Etchevers said:

          I did read that as eNtymology, Dr. Grump.

          May I recommend you join the Luxuriant Flowing Hair Club for Scientists™ if you are not already a long-standing member?

          Humbly yours.

        • Date:
          Sunday, 30 Nov 2008 - 23:04 UTC
          Stephen Curry said:

          Welcome to NN Dr Grump – happy to join you in battle against tendentious anti-science nonsense, wherever it may appear!

        • Date:
          Sunday, 30 Nov 2008 - 23:04 UTC
          Clare Dudman said:

          Thank you Heather, Dr Grump has indeed found much inspiration from the Luxuriant Flowing Hair Club for Scientists, and indeed there was a time when it used to be her exclusive source of dates.

          However, time moves on – and she now favours a less hirsute companion. In fact she now suspects many a masculine pony tail of being merely a compensatory gesture: as the hair recedes at the front so the hair at the back grows longer, almost as if the scalp is slipping backwards with age. She has already applied for a grant from the Uurm Foundation to make a further study of the phenomenon.

        • Date:
          Sunday, 30 Nov 2008 - 23:08 UTC
          Clare Dudman said:

          Aha, an ally! I am honoured to make your acquaintance, sir! I shall add you to the Grump network forthwith.

        • Date:
          Sunday, 30 Nov 2008 - 23:22 UTC
          Stephen Curry said:

          Ditto!

        • Date:
          Monday, 01 Dec 2008 - 05:26 UTC
          Henry Gee said:

          Yes. I think so. Unless you’re that eight-foot rabbit called Harvey. It’s hard to tell from this angle.

        • Date:
          Monday, 01 Dec 2008 - 05:37 UTC
          steffi suhr said:

          Welcome Dr. Grump! Will you change your profile picture, or keep using that of our companion Clare Dudman (as a cover)?

          Wrt ‘male pattern hair loss’: they say that those that loose hair in the front are great thinkers and those that lose it in the back are great lovers. Those that loose it in both places think they are great lovers..

        • Date:
          Monday, 01 Dec 2008 - 08:09 UTC
          Clare Dudman said:

          Thank you Steffi – two excellent points. The second, in particular, is priceless, and Dr Grump has added it to her little black and marked it with a star – an almost unheard-of honour.

          When I asked her about a photo, however, she was slightly less effusive. She is thinking about it, but suspect that, like the new Madame Sarkozy, her rates will be too high.

          Henry – did you have to mention Harvey? That topic is still out of bounds with Dr Grump. I think you know why.

        • Date:
          Monday, 01 Dec 2008 - 09:53 UTC
          Henry Gee said:

          I remain unrepentant. Just wait until Dr Grump hears what I’ve done with her ten-foot blue badger, Osbert.

        • Date:
          Monday, 01 Dec 2008 - 21:28 UTC
          Maxine Clarke said:

          I loved/was terrified by Struwwelpeter as a child. Of course I could not give or read it to my own children as long since banned (along with Helen Bannerman). Maybe just as well, especially that finger story. I still shudder! The film Edward Scissorhands was based on it, apparently.

        • Date:
          Monday, 01 Dec 2008 - 22:19 UTC
          Clare Dudman said:

          Dr Grump has now left the building. She has been having a bad day. At one stage I found her under her desk muttering about the her past catching up with her and asking me if I thought it was possible for ten feet tall rabbits to grow armour on their front, and did I think the ancestors of turtles had teeth sharp enough to remove the fingers of small boys. Frankly, when this happens, it is better to leave her well alone.

        • Date:
          Tuesday, 02 Dec 2008 - 05:11 UTC
          Henry Gee said:

          _I loved/was terrified by Struwwelpeter _

          I was just terrified. Didn’t know it had been banned, though.

        • Date:
          Tuesday, 02 Dec 2008 - 05:32 UTC
          steffi suhr said:

          Struwwelpeter: I just remember a certain horrified curiosity. The stories were just so out there.

          So Struwwelpeter is banned, and parents in my son’s daycare in Colorado let their 4 and 5-year olds watch Spiderman 3 and Star Wars Episode 3 – you know: Spiderman turns evil, Anakin kills a bunch of children and then crawls up on shore completely burned and only half alive…

          (I should add that this was a daycare with children of almost exclusively well-educated, successful people).

        • Date:
          Tuesday, 02 Dec 2008 - 05:35 UTC
          steffi suhr said:

          Hang on – where is it banned? I found it on amazon.de, co.uk, and com?..

        • Date:
          Tuesday, 02 Dec 2008 - 05:43 UTC
          steffi suhr said:

          I’m serial this morning: just found this aged, but very timely post by Dr. Grump’s colleague.

        • Date:
          Tuesday, 02 Dec 2008 - 08:42 UTC
          Clare Dudman said:

          You are right, Steffi – Struwwelpeter has not been banned in general – just in certain UK libraries, and, I suspect, for racial reasons rather than because it is considered to be too disturbing. It is not the tailor with the scissors who has won the librarian’s ire, but the scribe: when three boys laugh at the Moorish boy he reprimands them by telling them that the Moorish boy can’t help being black. When you think about it, this has a potentially stunning and devastating implication for any non-white child reader.

          This is ironic because Hoffmann himself fought against racial discrimination and was quite a campaigner for the only substantial racial minority that he did come across – the people of Judengasse.

          Personally, I think children love and in some way need to be unsettled when they read – hence the popularity of books like Roald Dahl’s. They need to know there are wicked things in the world. It gives them a chance to encounter them from a safe distance – the other side of the page – before becoming adults and meeting them face to face.

        • Date:
          Tuesday, 02 Dec 2008 - 09:57 UTC
          Henry Gee said:

          Yes, but it was the sad fate of Little Suck-A-Thumb that scared me shitless. They’d never allow it in Haringey. At least, not if they could help it.

        • Date:
          Tuesday, 02 Dec 2008 - 12:06 UTC
          Clare Dudman said:

          Yes, it’s the detail, really, isn’t it – the little pools of blood on the floor beneath the thumbless hands? As Maxine says – it delights and terrifies at the same time.


Search blogs

web feed Want a blog?

Submit this post to

Advertisement