Boston forum: topic

This is a public forum

Science education in Massachusetts comes out on top

Anna Kushnir

Thursday, 15 Jan 2009 02:30 UTC

An article in today’s Boston Globe reports that Mass 4th graders outperformed the rest of the nation on a science and math exam (TIMSS), “coming in second just behind Singapore and ahead of Taiwan, Hong Kong, and Japan.”

This and other tests now show that female students are performing as well or better than their male counterparts in math and science. Some specialists caution, however, that females are still less confident in these two subjects, leading Mass to consider teaching girls math separately from boys, basically re-enacting segregation in education.

I can certainly understand what they are getting at – creating a comfortable environment for girls to learn science and math, perhaps using an approach different from that used with boys. On the other hand, I am appalled by the proposition. It’s not healthy, and it’s a potential slippery slope to a huge double standard and further doubt of girls’ math skills.

What do you think? Is separate science education for girls and boys a viable solution to increasing girls’ confidence?

  • Replies

    Post a reply
    • When it comes to the benefits of any type of education, people begin with the most consistent in the abilities of boys and girls, how they are different, etc. But the truth is that no society has ever built a system of education according to ability. This issue remains controversial today. And in the past no one cared about it at all.

    • Can a world exist with only men or women?

      In my opinion, both are equal in capacity and opportunity.

      Every student in class is different and thus, differentiating on the basis of gender is not a good idea.

    Post a reply

Search forums Advanced search

web feed

Submit this topic to

In association with

alexandria

Advertisement