Science Writers forum: topic

This is a public forum

Asylum reviews Make Room! Make Room!

Maxine Clarke

Friday, 06 Feb 2009 12:53 UTC

Does anyone remember the book “Make Room! Make Room!” by Harry Harrison – written I think in the 1960s. I remember enjoying it years and years ago. It imagines the future, 1999, in which population has exploded. The story is about a New York cop, struggling to help control a city of 35 million, riddled with crimes (usually food stealing)? The book was made into a classic film (which I also enjoyed, and even have on DVD somewhere I think, remembering this fact – though I have not watched it), starring Charlton Heston, in the 1970s, with an added shock-horror element not in the book. John Self of Asylum blog has just reviewed the book#. (Asylum is a great blog, featuring reviews of books the writer likes reading, irrespective of when they were published). John posts an extract from the book describing how the catastrophe came about:
I’ll tell you what changed. Modern medicine arrived. Everything had a cure. Malaria was wiped out along with all the other diseases that had been killing people young and keeping the population down. Death control arrived. Old people lived longer. More babies lived who would have died, and now they grow up into old people who live longer still. People are still being fed into the world just as fast – they’re just not being taken out of it at the same rate. Three are born for every two that die. So the population doubles and doubles – and keeps on doubling at a quicker rate all the time. We got a plague of people, a disease of people infecting the world. We got more people who are living longer. Less people have to be born, that’s the answer. We got death control – we got to match it with birth control.
Interesting 1960s perspective on what the next 30 years would bring. Now we are ten years on from that envisaged future.

  • Replies

    Post a reply
    • Ah, Harry Harrison. For me, Harry Harrison means The Stainless Steel Rat, the Fourth Law of Robotics, and The Turing Option. While I remember reading Make Room! Make Room!, I was more affected by the plot of Soylent Green, which is based on it. The ending was desolation itself – the plankton were dying, and humanity was finished.

      And who would have thought in 1960 that the Guardian would publish a piece in 2007 about the Japanese preferring sleep to sex, thereby giving the government worries about the birth rate? The prediction: if the trend continues, the population will be 64M, about half of what it is today, at the end of the century. They are worrying about a decline now. I wonder how they will feel then, particularly if climate change can not be checked.

      According to a poll at the time by Durex (yes the very same), the Japanese have sex on average about once a week, while the world average is just over twice a week. Can these figures be right? The implication one is led to draw is that people are working too hard to want to have sex. Work – the new birth control. Who ever thought it could be so easy?

    Post a reply

Search forums Advanced search

web feed

Submit this topic to

Advertisement