• The End Of The Pier Show

    Described by Carl Zimmer as "one of my favorite wastes of time", The End Of The Pier Show is the online scratching post of Nature Editor, Norfolk resident and sometime "garage-band monster" Henry Gee and his amazing unicycling girrafes.

    • Witless Quote-Mining

      Tuesday, 11 Dec 2007 - 09:57 GMT

      The habit of theatre managers of extracting tiny nuggets of hope from otherwise dreadful notices is probably too much of a cliche to be worth a mention. You know, when Boot of The Beast writes

      The prospect of a revival of Noel Coward’s Cavalcade filled me with breathless excitement, but the pathetic excuse offered at the Pyrexicon Theatre last night was no more exciting than a west Tuesday afternoon in Romford…

      you’ll see posters outside the theatre next day proclaiming

      Breathless ExcitementDaily Beast

      Many years ago when the world was young I wrote a book suggesting that the traditional, narrative mode of evolutionary story-telling had been surpassed by the new, rigorous and above all scientific discipline of cladistics.

      I was warned that when I said that to place a lot of fossils in a line and draw arrows between them is no way to create a credible model of evolution, I’d be jumped on by creationist quote-miners, and so I was. My apparent support for creationist rubbish is all over the web like a cheap suit.

      My response was (and still is) is that creationists are so desperate to acquire credibility that they’d twist one’s words any old how, whatever you said – and that I wasn’t about to modify my pronouncements to accommodate this particular bunch of bozos. That my stance is justified comes from the fact that no matter how loudly I state that creationism is a consignment of geriatric shoe manufacturers, they’ll still rip me off for quotes just the same. They just want to be close to me, I guess… maybe I should turn my charisma down a notch, and they’ll just drift away.

      I had thought that people who write marketing and advertising blurb for publishers occupied a rung on the scala naturae slightly above creationists. This may be true, but whatever the height of their perch, it is still below that of estate agents, as judged from this flyer from Oxford University Press promoting James D. Watson’s latest effusion, Avoid Boring People, in which you’ll see this puff:

      ’...an engaging writer…’ – Dr Henry Gee, Focus

      Well, it’s quite true that I reviewed the book for Focus, and also true that I said Watson was ‘an engaging writer’, because he is.

      But it’s very annoying, and, indeed, quite offensive, to see this highly selective quote plastered all over the web in support of this book, when the rest of my review made it clear, given the circumlocutions required when one is offered a lead review slot and one doesn’t want to cast too much of a downer on things, that, in my humble opinion, Avoid Boring People by James D Watson is an arrogant, illiterate, narcissistic, pompous, pustulocrustaceous, shrill, noisome, vile, risible and above all steamingly feculent carcass of a book whose purpose can only be to distract me from from more worthwhile pursuits such as listening to my collection of tapes of kittens being impaled on red-hot skewers. Now, I’d like to see OUP put that in their publicity.

      Last updated: Tuesday, 11 Dec 2007 - 09:57 GMT

        • all tags

          • No tags for this post.
      • Comments

        • Date:
          Tuesday, 11 Dec 2007 - 10:11 GMT
          Richard Grant said:

          Um, ah, I wonder if, well I don’t like to say it really, but, ah, kittens? on skewers?

          Can I borrow the tapes, please?

        • Date:
          Tuesday, 11 Dec 2007 - 14:23 GMT
          Carl Zimmer said:

          Hail, fellow quote-minee. I reviewed the same book for Publisher’s Weekly (scroll to the bottom here ) Fairly negative. Compare that with what appears on the publisher’s web page for the book: ‘Entertaining and historically revealing’—Carl Zimmer.

          Sigh.

        • Date:
          Tuesday, 11 Dec 2007 - 14:55 GMT
          Henry Gee said:

          Hah! Carl, I wish I could find a version of my Focus review online, because it was much less kind than yours in PW. I can’t remember ever having written a more savage, sarcatic mauling of anything, ever, because the book is that dreadful, and even given my parting, Parthian shot that unless one can find something nice to say about other people, one should shut up. The part about Watson being an engaging writer really was the only nice thing I said.

        • Date:
          Wednesday, 12 Dec 2007 - 18:57 GMT
          Carl Zimmer said:

          Every word counts.

        • Date:
          Friday, 14 Dec 2007 - 16:36 GMT
          Daniel Cressey said:

          My favourite example of this is when the Guardian gave a stand up comedian one star out of five. His publicity material then proudly proclaimed:
          “A star” says The Guardian.


Search blogs

web feed Want a blog?

Submit this post to

Advertisement